Today's Opportunities are live — See 35 stocks with strong momentum today →

Advertisement

Nigerian Diaspora Wealth Builder - Buy Now on Amazon

How to Know If an NGX Stock Is Actually Worth Buying | Smart Investor’s Guide to NGX Stocks (Part 2 of 3)

Build a valuation range using sustainable earnings, comparable businesses and downside assumptions rather than a low price alone.

Premium educational image featuring AIICO Insurance Plc stock fundamentals on TopChor highlighting P/E, EPS, dividend yield, ROE, and Price-to-Book analysis.

A good company still needs a sensible purchase price

An attractive business can be an unattractive investment when its share price already assumes exceptional success. Conversely, a low valuation may reflect a damaged business rather than a bargain. The purpose of valuation is to connect the price you pay with the economic benefits you reasonably expect to receive.

Part one examined earnings, cash flow and debt. This second part brings those findings into a valuation range. All calculations below are hypothetical and exclude dealing charges unless stated otherwise. They are not claims about any company's actual price on June 3, 2026.

Begin with the whole company

Market capitalisation equals the share price multiplied by shares outstanding. A company with two billion ordinary shares trading at ₦40 has an equity market value of ₦80 billion.

A ₦5 share is not automatically cheaper than a ₦50 share. The number of shares and the earnings attached to each share matter. After a bonus issue or split, the quoted price may fall even when the business's overall value has changed little.

Write down the share count and its date. A recently completed capital raise can make an old valuation misleading. Check whether the price and financial figures reflect the same corporate-action adjustments.

Price to earnings is a starting point

The price-to-earnings ratio, or P/E, divides the share price by EPS. A ₦40 price and ₦5 EPS produce a P/E of eight times. That means the price equals eight years of that particular annual earnings figure; it does not promise repayment in eight years.

Ask whether the earnings are repeatable. Asset disposals, currency gains and unusual tax credits may temporarily increase profit. A low P/E based on exceptional earnings can conceal an expensive investment.

Compare similar companies using the same accounting period and basis. Trailing earnings are historical. Forecast earnings involve assumptions. A forecast P/E should be labelled as such, with the earnings estimate and its author identified.

Book value requires a quality check

Price to book compares the share price with net assets per share. If book value per share is ₦60 and the price is ₦40, the ratio is approximately 0.67 times.

That discount may deserve attention, particularly in financial businesses, but book value is not a promise of cash shareholders can collect. Bad loans, doubtful receivables, obsolete equipment and overvalued investments can weaken the apparent cushion.

For banks, review asset quality, capital adequacy and sustainable return on equity alongside price to book. A bank earning poor returns on its equity may deserve a lower multiple than a stronger competitor. A premium can be reasonable, but it still needs an earnings explanation.

Dividend yield needs sustainable cash

Dividend yield equals annual dividend per share divided by purchase price. An illustrative ₦3 dividend on a ₦40 price gives a 7.5% gross yield.

Check whether the figure includes a special dividend and whether the payment has already been made. A historical yield does not guarantee the next distribution. Debt, regulation, investment spending and weaker profits can all reduce future payments.

Compare dividend income with cash generation and the payout ratio. A company distributing more than it can sustainably earn and fund may eventually need to cut the dividend or raise new capital. A falling share price can make the quoted yield look generous precisely when the underlying income is becoming less secure.

Build scenarios instead of one precise target

Valuation is sensitive to assumptions. Suppose you estimate sustainable EPS at ₦5. Applying illustrative P/E multiples of six, eight and ten produces values of ₦30, ₦40 and ₦50 respectively.

These are scenarios, not objective facts. Explain why a multiple might be justified by growth, financial strength and comparable businesses. Then test lower earnings. If EPS falls to ₦3, even an eight-times multiple implies only ₦24.

This downside case matters more than an attractive upside percentage. A margin of safety means leaving room for reasonable errors and adverse outcomes; it cannot make a weak business safe. Avoid choosing assumptions merely because they produce a value above the market price.

Compare alternatives on a consistent basis

Equities compete with cash, Treasury bills, bonds and other investments. A share's possible capital gain is uncertain, whereas a fixed-income instrument may specify contractual payments subject to its terms and risks.

Use comparable holding periods, taxes, currency and reinvestment assumptions. A forecast equity total return should include plausible dividends and price outcomes, rather than treating dividend yield alone as the full return. Consider liquidity and the possibility that the money will be needed before the thesis develops.

Write your decision before placing an order

Summarise the business, sustainable earnings estimate, valuation range, downside risks and maximum portfolio allocation. State what evidence would change your view. If you cannot explain why the current price is attractive without referring to a recent rally, the research is unfinished.

The next part considers entry timing. Valuation narrows the acceptable price range; execution determines whether the actual purchase respects that range. Neither step guarantees a profit.

Treat financial and operating companies differently

Enterprise value can help compare some non-financial businesses with different financing structures. In a simplified calculation, it combines equity market value with debt and deducts cash. The precise calculation may also require adjustments for leases, minority interests and other claims. Use a consistent definition before comparing companies.

A cash-rich business and a heavily indebted business can have the same equity market value while presenting very different economic obligations. Earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation can offer another perspective, but that measure excludes real capital spending needs and should not be confused with distributable cash.

For banks, deposits and lending are part of the operating model. An industrial-company enterprise-value framework is therefore usually less informative than capital, asset quality, sustainable return on equity and appropriate equity valuation measures.

Avoid attaching an industry multiple to a company without examining why the market assigns it. Differences in governance, funding costs, growth prospects and disclosure quality may justify different prices. A peer comparison is evidence to interpret, not a mechanical instruction to move every company toward the sector average. The valuation should remain intelligible when the chosen peer group changes slightly.

Investor Insight

A valuation range is only as reliable as the earnings assumptions and downside cases that support it.

D

Dr. Babs Odunsi

Dr. Babs Odunsi is a financial expert focused on explaining stock market fundamentals and investment concepts in simple, practical terms.

More articles by Dr. Babs Odunsi →