Do Stocks Rise More Than They Fall? Comparing the NGX, S&P 500, and Nasdaq Over 10 Years (2016–2025)
Compare market history using consistent return measures and understand why the number of positive years is only part of the result.
Define what rising more often actually means
The question sounds simple: do stock markets rise more often than they fall? Yet the answer depends on whether we count trading days, calendar months or complete years. It also depends on which index, currency and return measure we use.
For a comparison covering 2016–2025, the proper annual sample is ten complete calendar years. It begins with the last trading close of 2015 and ends with the last trading close of 2025. Information from 2026 cannot be added to that historical window merely because the article is being restored later.
Use comparable benchmarks
The NGX All-Share Index measures a Nigerian equity market benchmark. The S&P 500 represents large US companies selected under its methodology. The Nasdaq Composite covers common-type stocks listed on Nasdaq and is different from the Nasdaq-100.
These indexes differ in sector concentration, constituents, market structure and currency. A comparison can be useful without making them interchangeable investments. The naira return on Nigerian shares and the dollar return on US shares answer different questions for a diaspora investor.
Decide whether the study concerns price return or total return. Price return measures changes in the index level. Total return adds distributions under the methodology's reinvestment assumptions. Mixing an NGX price index with a US total-return index can make the comparison look precise while answering inconsistent questions.
Calculate each year consistently
For each benchmark, annual price return equals the year-end closing index level divided by the previous year-end level, minus one. Multiply by 100 to express the result as a percentage.
If a hypothetical index closes one year at 10,000 and the next at 11,500, its price return is 15%. If it then falls to 10,350, the following year's return is minus 10%.
Record the last actual trading date where December 31 is not a trading day. Use the same official index series throughout the sample. Changes in index constituents are handled by the index methodology; manually inserting today's winners into earlier years would introduce hindsight.
Distinguish frequency from magnitude
An index can rise in more years than it falls and still deliver an unsatisfactory result. Consider an illustrative three-year sequence of plus 10%, plus 10% and minus 30%.
An initial ₦100 becomes ₦110, then ₦121, then ₦84.70. Two of the three years were positive, but the cumulative outcome was a loss of 15.3% before dividends, taxes and costs.
The size and sequence of gains and losses therefore matter alongside the percentage of positive years. A 50% loss requires a 100% gain merely to regain the starting value. Positive-year frequency should never be presented as a probability that an individual investor will profit over the next year.
Two historical observations with clear limits
NGX reported that its All-Share Index gained 37.65% in 2024 and 51.19% in 2025. Those are two positive annual observations, rather than proof of a complete ten-year pattern. The NGX releases were published before this article's June 4, 2026 date.
S&P Dow Jones Indices reported a 16.39% S&P 500 price gain for 2025 and a 17.88% return including dividends. The difference illustrates why return definitions must remain consistent across markets.
These observations do not establish which benchmark performed best across all ten years. A complete study requires the full annual series for each index. The missing historical comparison should not be filled using remembered figures, rounded social-media graphics or an undocumented ranking.
Measure compound growth and drawdowns
Compound annual growth rate equals the ending value divided by the starting value, raised to one divided by the number of years, minus one. It describes an equivalent steady annual rate, although the actual journey is uneven.
Also review the worst annual return and the maximum drawdown during the period. Annual data can hide a substantial fall and recovery within the same year. An investor withdrawing money during a downturn may experience a different result from someone who holds throughout.
Account for implementation. An index does not pay your brokerage charges, foreign-exchange spread or personal taxes. An investable fund may introduce fees and tracking differences. Those costs can change a practical decision even where the benchmark comparison is correct.
Compare in the currency of your goal
Suppose a Nigerian investment gains 30% in naira while the naira-per-dollar exchange rate rises 40%. Its approximate dollar return is 1.30 divided by 1.40, minus one: a loss of about 7.1%, before costs.
The example is hypothetical, but the relationship is important. A strong local-currency return may coexist with a weak foreign-currency outcome. Inflation creates a separate purchasing-power question within each currency.
Use history to improve the plan
Historical market recoveries can support patience and diversification, but they do not guarantee that every stock will recover or that a chosen holding period will be profitable. Failed companies can disappear while a broad index continues.
The useful next step is to assemble the official 2015–2025 year-end series, calculate the ten annual returns consistently, and label the currency and dividend basis. Until that work is complete, claims about exact positive-year counts or ten-year market rankings remain unverified.
Keep contributions separate from market performance
A comparison of indexes assumes a specified amount invested under a defined methodology. A real investor may contribute monthly, withdraw for expenses or reinvest distributions at different times. The return on those cash flows can differ from the benchmark's start-to-end return.
Suppose an index rises strongly before most of an investor's money is added. The account may show a large closing balance while the investor earned relatively little on the new contributions. Conversely, regular purchases during a decline can change the outcome of a subsequent recovery. Neither result invalidates the index calculation; it answers a different question.
When presenting a personal example, show contribution dates and amounts separately from gains. Money-weighted and time-weighted returns measure different aspects of the experience, so identify which is being used.
Do not compare an account balance that includes fresh savings with an index that assumes no added capital. Keep the study reproducible by documenting cash-flow assumptions, distributions and fees. This discipline also prevents a historical chart from implying that every investor who participated in those years received the same outcome. The market's path and the investor's decisions both matter.
Investor Insight
The frequency of positive years is only one part of the return story; the size of losses can matter more.
Dr. Babs Odunsi
Dr. Babs Odunsi is a financial expert focused on explaining stock market fundamentals and investment concepts in simple, practical terms.
More articles by Dr. Babs Odunsi →